Jay Romero is on the ground, perusing Christmas gifts. When his stepsister Molly Little and her companion Katie Kush discover him, they choose to play pranks on him. They inform him that he will receive a unique gift, but it won't be beneath the tree quite yet.
When Jay gets back, the girls will have just completed packing Molly's ass into a box. He loves his ass in a box very much! Molly and Katie feel that it would be awesome if Jay fucked Molly, so Katie tells him to go for it.
Jay still believes that the buttocks and pussy are phony, just like his stepsis in the dog. Fully engaged, Katie takes off her tan lined underwear to flirt with Jay while he hosts Molly's party.
Katie pulls aside the blanket covering Molly as soon as she starts to scream from her climax, telling Jay that he has been having an affair with his stepsister all along. The show is over, but the celebration continues. The females give Jay a double BJ by getting down on their knees.
Then Katie scales the top to ride Jay's cowgirl fuck stick. After reaching their climaxes, the females lay down side Jay pulls out right in time to grant Molly's request when she begs him to cover her in come. After sucking the tip and licking some of Molly's stomach, Katie gives her best friend a long, cummy kiss.
Stevie Shae discovers her college course is taught by her sister's former lover. She makes advances towards him, expressing her desire for sex. Professor Hunter tries to soften his tone, but Stevie beats him before class, proving she excelled in a rhetoric course.
Mikey Butders unexpectedly encounters his ex-wife, Becca Blossom, causing intense emotions and nostalgia. They share a passionate bond, and Mikey happily obliges.
Kaylee discovers her lab partner, Michael, is tampering with their experiment and hiding them. She decides to get to know him by giving him a messy blowjob, showcasing her skills.
Rocco, Holly's friend's husband, observes her masturbating and approaches her. Despite her initial opposition, Rocco convinces her to have multiple orgasms.
Jessie Rogers and her girlfriend spend time online, while Bruce, her brother's brother, sends them to watch sports highlights. Jessie discovers Bruce masturbating in his room, revealing she has seen a large dick and wants to eat every inch of his body.
Professor Magnum informs Katie Zane of her selection for an elite, double-secret sign language group, warning her that these three suggestive indicators will only help her through the semester and future studies.
Amber Ashlee's supervisor discovers an offensive email revealing graphic sexual actions, and despite being eligible for termination, she refuses to be dismissed. The supervisor suggests that if Amber behaves like the image, he might keep her on board.
Michael supports Tiffany at a dinner, having supported her since childhood. His mother, Annabelle, admires Michael's appearance. However, Tiffany's lover demands her, leaving Annabelle and Michael in disbelief. Annabelle must show Michael's appreciation at home.
Christie Stevens invites her lustful husband, who watches her in a warm bath, for steamy fun. She shows off her dildo, slides his cock down her throat, and rides it hard.
Lia Lor is unsure of her career goals and desires to travel before pursuing a profession. Professor Strong advises her to take time and find a solution. However, Lia Lor's decision to fuck her professor before graduation raises questions about her future.